What is your ERE housing score?
Re: What is your ERE housing score?
Now:
5.1 + 0 (combined with work trip) + 190/100 = 7
When moved:
8.1 + 0 (combined with work trip) + 0 = 8.1
Housing goes down, but transportation goes up with move, hmm. Maybe one day the hubby can figure out how to work from home, then we'd still have the grocery trip and not really have any difference. Guess then we would need to be growing more than 50% of our food from home, which is the goal.
5.1 + 0 (combined with work trip) + 190/100 = 7
When moved:
8.1 + 0 (combined with work trip) + 0 = 8.1
Housing goes down, but transportation goes up with move, hmm. Maybe one day the hubby can figure out how to work from home, then we'd still have the grocery trip and not really have any difference. Guess then we would need to be growing more than 50% of our food from home, which is the goal.
Re: What is your ERE housing score?
(62'000/400+120-700)/100+0+0=-4.25
own house with mortgage while living in the garage, tenant pays a rent, no working, dumpster food wherever I happen to be while my supply are low, occasionaly walk to the grocery.
A more honest way to put it would be to say
50/100+0+5*0.3=2
Because I lowered the rent to move in the garage, and the big grocery where i can get stapples is 5 miles away, and me walking doesn't make the housing more efficient.
own house with mortgage while living in the garage, tenant pays a rent, no working, dumpster food wherever I happen to be while my supply are low, occasionaly walk to the grocery.
A more honest way to put it would be to say
50/100+0+5*0.3=2
Because I lowered the rent to move in the garage, and the big grocery where i can get stapples is 5 miles away, and me walking doesn't make the housing more efficient.
Re: What is your ERE housing score?
9 miles by car and 9 by bike to go to work = 9+(9*0.3)= 11.7
0 To grocery store
400€/100 = 4
11.7+0+4= 15.7 ... I'm pretty good
0 To grocery store
400€/100 = 4
11.7+0+4= 15.7 ... I'm pretty good
Re: What is your ERE housing score?
I'd argue that living closer to work at half the distance is preferable to carpooling the full distance even though you're driving the same amount. But carpooling should be incentivized, so for this situation use the public transit modifier (0.7*distance).prognastat wrote: ↑Fri Jun 22, 2018 8:44 pmIf we carpool to work and it's the same location(which we do) do we get to half our work commute score?
-
- Posts: 991
- Joined: Fri May 04, 2018 8:30 pm
- Location: Texas
- Contact:
Re: What is your ERE housing score?
Alright, that would change it to.Fish wrote: ↑Sun Jun 24, 2018 4:20 amI'd argue that living closer to work at half the distance is preferable to carpooling the full distance even though you're driving the same amount. But carpooling should be incentivized, so for this situation use the public transit modifier (0.7*distance).prognastat wrote: ↑Fri Jun 22, 2018 8:44 pmIf we carpool to work and it's the same location(which we do) do we get to half our work commute score?
11.3 miles to work by car -> 7.9
1.4 miles to grocery store by car ->1.4
$1500/month for 2 adults on housing -> 7.5
Total = 16.8
-
- Posts: 1003
- Joined: Sat Oct 18, 2014 12:49 pm
Re: What is your ERE housing score?
2.5 miles to work by car -> 2.5 (I biked this for a month...until I met a car windshield I didn't get along with)
0.8 miles to grocery store by car -> 0.8
1232/2/100 -> 6.2
9.5, but looking to raise it to 30+
0.8 miles to grocery store by car -> 0.8
1232/2/100 -> 6.2
9.5, but looking to raise it to 30+
-
- Posts: 1240
- Joined: Thu Feb 12, 2015 2:14 pm
- Location: Falls City, OR
Re: What is your ERE housing score?
Depending on how crappy the roads are with traffic, 11.3 miles is a really nice bike commute distance.
-
- Posts: 991
- Joined: Fri May 04, 2018 8:30 pm
- Location: Texas
- Contact:
Re: What is your ERE housing score?
Well being central Texas I would arrive at work drenched and the infrastructure isn't there for biking most of it. only 1/3rd at most has any kind of bike lane/shoulder.enigmaT120 wrote: ↑Tue Jun 26, 2018 9:39 pmDepending on how crappy the roads are with traffic, 11.3 miles is a really nice bike commute distance.
Plus even if I did I'd never be able to convince my wife to bike that distance and since we carpool it would mean no savings, counting the wear on the bike means it would actually increase my cost if we didn't both do it. Even more so if you count the time saved by driving in comparison and how much I'd make if I worked that time instead.
Re: What is your ERE housing score?
Small town Michigan
Don't work: 0, I walked to work before FIRE.
Aldi 2 miles, Walmart 2 miles, Meijer 1 mile, I will use Aldi because they are cheapest. We drive but could easily bike or walk.
Own house, two occupants: ((96k*0.03/12) + (3k/12) )/2
0+2+2.45 = 4.45
Don't work: 0, I walked to work before FIRE.
Aldi 2 miles, Walmart 2 miles, Meijer 1 mile, I will use Aldi because they are cheapest. We drive but could easily bike or walk.
Own house, two occupants: ((96k*0.03/12) + (3k/12) )/2
0+2+2.45 = 4.45
Re: What is your ERE housing score?
Other location items of interest:
Goodwill or thrift shop, library, farmers market, park, beach or green area, bike path for exercise, wilderness for camping, healthcare, hardware building supply.
Goodwill or thrift shop, library, farmers market, park, beach or green area, bike path for exercise, wilderness for camping, healthcare, hardware building supply.
Re: What is your ERE housing score?
@Jean could you post some pictures of your garage. I am really interest in your living situation .
Re: What is your ERE housing score?
@thegreatvoid
It's not very intersting. I'm waiting for a building permit. There was a wood storage place over it. I moved the wood and cut away a part of the floor, and put a bed on the rest of it. I have about 4 cubic meter.
It's not very intersting. I'm waiting for a building permit. There was a wood storage place over it. I moved the wood and cut away a part of the floor, and put a bed on the rest of it. I have about 4 cubic meter.
Re: What is your ERE housing score?
@thegreatvoid
bOk, I made some crappy pictures
bOk, I made some crappy pictures
-
- Posts: 1635
- Joined: Thu Nov 19, 2015 11:20 am
- Location: Earth
Re: What is your ERE housing score?
Score 8.5 = (Distance to work in miles- 0) + (Distance to grocery in miles + 3 * 1.0= 3) + (Monthly cost of housing in 1100/2/100 = 5.5)
Bam!
Work from home, drive 3 miles to get groceries 1x per week, and pay 550 for my half of rent in a 1 bedroom apartment which includes all utilities, Wifi, use of a large yard/garden, in a HCOL area.
The only downside is that it's a basement (but has 2 smaller 1'x2.5' windows and one decent 3.5'x2' one. A separate storage room for our bicycles and a long hallway which acts as a mudroom.
Bam!
Work from home, drive 3 miles to get groceries 1x per week, and pay 550 for my half of rent in a 1 bedroom apartment which includes all utilities, Wifi, use of a large yard/garden, in a HCOL area.
The only downside is that it's a basement (but has 2 smaller 1'x2.5' windows and one decent 3.5'x2' one. A separate storage room for our bicycles and a long hallway which acts as a mudroom.
Re: What is your ERE housing score?
1*18.5 + 1*2.5 + 332/100 = 24.3 room for improvement.
however when retired:
1*0 + 1*2.5 + 332/100 = 5.8
however when retired:
1*0 + 1*2.5 + 332/100 = 5.8
Re: What is your ERE housing score?
Walk to work and grocery. 720 rent.
So 0 + 0 +720/100 = 7.2
So 0 + 0 +720/100 = 7.2
Re: What is your ERE housing score?
1*1 + 2*1 + 367/100 = 6.67
Where you get screwed is if you have a long commute.
Where you get screwed is if you have a long commute.
Re: What is your ERE housing score?
8km*0.621*0.3=1.47
2.4km by bike = 0
1000€/m /100 = 10
11.47 doesn't sound to bad but:
- I still need a car for my work, hard to circumvent that one
- shouldn't energy costs, at least for heating, not be included in the formula? Even with lowering the room temp and putting on more/better adapted clothes the isolation of your house makes a major difference in heating costs. Here in NW Europe heating is a bill to be taken in account..
Otoh I try to lower that with my new woodstove and free garbage wood
2.4km by bike = 0
1000€/m /100 = 10
11.47 doesn't sound to bad but:
- I still need a car for my work, hard to circumvent that one
- shouldn't energy costs, at least for heating, not be included in the formula? Even with lowering the room temp and putting on more/better adapted clothes the isolation of your house makes a major difference in heating costs. Here in NW Europe heating is a bill to be taken in account..
Otoh I try to lower that with my new woodstove and free garbage wood
Re: What is your ERE housing score?
I would say that this housing score is gives a good general idea of your situation, you could make your own scheme with all the things you find important and weight them appropriately.
Re: What is your ERE housing score?
Thanks Fish, that was fun!
erewig's results:
Work from home 4 days per week commute in 1 day (via bike + pub trans) so i took the distance and divided by 5 = 3.08
Distance to grocery in miles = 2
Monthly cost of housing in USD = 857 + council tax 141 + util 94 = $1092 at current exchange rate /100 =10.9
= 15.98 Acceptable (C)
Lower than I was expecting seeing as I WFH 4 days a week.
Oh well, within a couple months we'll be living with family + building a tiny house so housing costs are going to plummet...
erewig's results:
Work from home 4 days per week commute in 1 day (via bike + pub trans) so i took the distance and divided by 5 = 3.08
Distance to grocery in miles = 2
Monthly cost of housing in USD = 857 + council tax 141 + util 94 = $1092 at current exchange rate /100 =10.9
= 15.98 Acceptable (C)
Lower than I was expecting seeing as I WFH 4 days a week.
Oh well, within a couple months we'll be living with family + building a tiny house so housing costs are going to plummet...