"Why I Make Terrible Decisions,or,poverty thoughts"

Favorite quotations, etc.
1taskaday
Posts: 414
Joined: Wed Dec 04, 2013 11:45 am
Location: England

"Why I Make Terrible Decisions,or,poverty thoughts"

Post by 1taskaday »

Just heard Linda Tirado author of "Why I Make Terrible Decisions,or,poverty thoughts" 2013 essay interviewed to-day and found it strangely compelling and moving.

I don't know whether it was as a female viewpoint or just the honesty of it that moved me the most.

Just learned a lot from it about why they often end up with the disastrous long-term results of such "poor" short-term decisions, (especially the women that end up with lots of kids by different fathers and no support).

Kind of made me feel guilty for the way I may have "judged “ them in the past...how dumb was I...

ffj
Posts: 2046
Joined: Thu Aug 26, 2010 3:16 am

Re: "Why I Make Terrible Decisions,or,poverty thoughts"

Post by ffj »

Read this before you get too attached to her plight:

http://blogs.houstonpress.com/artattack ... hts_es.php


I read her essay a few weeks ago and my bullshit meter was going off so I did a little more research. She is playing a tune that obviously many people are succumbing to. Why is that? That's an honest question and I would appreciate others thoughts.

ffj
Posts: 2046
Joined: Thu Aug 26, 2010 3:16 am

Re: "Why I Make Terrible Decisions,or,poverty thoughts"

Post by ffj »


GandK
Posts: 2022
Joined: Mon Sep 19, 2011 1:00 pm

Re: "Why I Make Terrible Decisions,or,poverty thoughts"

Post by GandK »

Jeff, I don't think it's BS. I think it's AS.

I think this is probably a woman on the autism spectrum. Both her writing and her choices are screaming it. This is a woman with high intelligence but extremely poor executive function. IOW, she's great at gathering information but but she literally lacks the skill/ability to follow through on much of anything, to include things like personal grooming. And people are standing around debating her advantages and her education now without looking at her subsequent actions.

If I'm right, then she's probably correct that she can't climb out of poverty, at least not without help. But she's completely mistaken about the cause. Her situation is about her, not about the system.

Dragline
Posts: 4452
Joined: Wed Aug 24, 2011 1:50 am

Re: "Why I Make Terrible Decisions,or,poverty thoughts"

Post by Dragline »

More broadly, the low empathy spectrum, which includes harmless autistics to devilish psychopaths. I would have guessed a borderline personality with all the personal drama/chaos, appeals for pity and casual dishonesty. When intelligent and articulate, they can be quite seductive.

Definitely someone to avoid. Feel sorry for her husband/family -- these people bring chaos into their personal relationships wherever they go. They have a compulsive need to create conflict and drama.

And not a good representative of most poor people (or most any people, for that matter).

7Wannabe5
Posts: 5538
Joined: Fri Oct 18, 2013 9:03 am

Re: "Why I Make Terrible Decisions,or,poverty thoughts"

Post by 7Wannabe5 »

For compare/contrast purposes, I recommend "The Bag Lady Papers: The Priceless Experience of Losing It All" by Alexandra Penney.

Dragline
Posts: 4452
Joined: Wed Aug 24, 2011 1:50 am

Re: "Why I Make Terrible Decisions,or,poverty thoughts"

Post by Dragline »

Great analogy. I have not read that book myself, but I appreciated these reviews: http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0036F6WYE?btkr=1

The mis-placed drama and self-pity is manifest. Ironic that the perpetrator in that book was another zero empathy character.

7Wannabe5
Posts: 5538
Joined: Fri Oct 18, 2013 9:03 am

Re: "Why I Make Terrible Decisions,or,poverty thoughts"

Post by 7Wannabe5 »

Dragline said: The mis-placed drama and self-pity is manifest. Ironic that the perpetrator in that book was another zero empathy character.
Right. Like many of Madoff's "victims", the author was partly sucked in by the ego gratification of being part of the in-crowd. The sad, scary detail of her story is that investing with Madoff was recommended to her by her therapist with whom she clearly had tranference relationship (So, he was almost in the equivalent role of the baby-Daddies in the above essay. Weak feminine chink in her otherwise well-defended coat of armor.) However, my take-away was that, beyond her social connections, she was able to save herself because she had established many good work and some good thrift habits.

Riggerjack
Posts: 2810
Joined: Thu Jul 14, 2011 3:09 am

Re: "Why I Make Terrible Decisions,or,poverty thoughts"

Post by Riggerjack »

That was a fun read. Except for the working parts, it could've been written by my mom, or any of the drugged up burnouts I grew up with. It isn't poor executive decision making. It is fully rational.

When your planning horizon is at best a few days out, best long term outcomes are not even influencing factors. Do what feels good now, because you can. Whatever money you have is less than you need, so you might as well have some fun. This comes from a world view where the man is keeping you down, and there is no hope of improvement. More money doesn't help. It doesn't hurt, but it doesn't help. It just gets turned into more toys/drugs/entertainment.

As to the author, yeah, that's fraud. Deception for profit is the definition of fraud. I hope she gets prosecuted. But as she was a liberal political hack, I can see how the line was blurry for her.

GandK
Posts: 2022
Joined: Mon Sep 19, 2011 1:00 pm

Re: "Why I Make Terrible Decisions,or,poverty thoughts"

Post by GandK »

Riggerjack wrote:But as she was a liberal political hack, I can see how the line was blurry for her.
:lol:

Devil's Advocate
Posts: 187
Joined: Wed Apr 09, 2014 8:25 am

Re: "Why I Make Terrible Decisions,or,poverty thoughts"

Post by Devil's Advocate »

Here’s what I found curious. Apparently there were some who, despite having donated themselves, despite having sent their own personal money to this girl, nevertheless staunchly support both their donation decision and the writer of the blog. In the Comments section. It would seem these people are really big-hearted, if you take this at face value. They’re saying, this girl said what she said, and we gave her money, and we don’t regret it, so what’s everyone else’s problem? And they do have a point when they say that. Seen in that light, those who criticize do come across as petty, given that the donors themselves don’t seem to mind.

On the other hand : perhaps they (the donors who’ve posted their comments there) just don’t like admitting to themselves that they’ve thrown good money away, and so find themselves defending the girl (and hence their own decision)?

Third possibility : I suppose it’s the easiest thing in the world for the writer of a blog to assume a fictitious identity (or perhaps a whole string of fictitious identities) and then go admiring their own articles and decisions in the Comments section. What better way for a blog to portray an appearance of popularity—and perhaps attract more kudos, thanks to herd mentality?

Perhaps that is what is happening here? After all, if you can deceive in one way, no reason why you won’t in other ways as well.

EMJ
Posts: 343
Joined: Sat Nov 20, 2010 6:37 pm

Re: "Why I Make Terrible Decisions,or,poverty thoughts"

Post by EMJ »

@Devil's Advocate:
1. Why do you call "a married mother of two" a girl?
2. Would you be fine with being called a boy?

Dragline
Posts: 4452
Joined: Wed Aug 24, 2011 1:50 am

Re: "Why I Make Terrible Decisions,or,poverty thoughts"

Post by Dragline »

Devil's Advocate wrote:Here’s what I found curious. Apparently there were some who, despite having donated themselves, despite having sent their own personal money to this girl, nevertheless staunchly support both their donation decision and the writer of the blog. In the Comments section. It would seem these people are really big-hearted, if you take this at face value. They’re saying, this girl said what she said, and we gave her money, and we don’t regret it, so what’s everyone else’s problem? And they do have a point when they say that. Seen in that light, those who criticize do come across as petty, given that the donors themselves don’t seem to mind.

On the other hand : perhaps they (the donors who’ve posted their comments there) just don’t like admitting to themselves that they’ve thrown good money away, and so find themselves defending the girl (and hence their own decision)?
The latter is the usual human approach -- decisions are made based on visceral impressions and justifying them comes after-the-fact.

GandK
Posts: 2022
Joined: Mon Sep 19, 2011 1:00 pm

Re: "Why I Make Terrible Decisions,or,poverty thoughts"

Post by GandK »

Dragline wrote:The latter is the usual human approach -- decisions are made based on visceral impressions and justifying them comes after-the-fact.
That's very true.
EMJ wrote: @Devil's Advocate:
1. Why do you call "a married mother of two" a girl?
2. Would you be fine with being called a boy?
First, I'm certain he wasn't trying to be insulting. DA loves to post in all the most controversial threads on this forum and he generally takes great care with his posts. I don't ever recall him being deliberately inflammatory.

Second, although I don't remember him ever saying this explicitly, his turn of phrase suggests a British, not an American, English education. And in Britain, saying "girl" when referring to any female (or "boy" for a male) is perfectly acceptable. It's not an insult.

Perhaps the benefit of the doubt is in order? :)

1taskaday
Posts: 414
Joined: Wed Dec 04, 2013 11:45 am
Location: England

Re: "Why I Make Terrible Decisions,or,poverty thoughts"

Post by 1taskaday »

Who would have known?-certainly not me from listening to her being interviewed on radio by very credible interviewers in Europe.

I just heard an interview and thought, wow, that makes so much sense and explains so many things that I could never understand about short-term planning and never getting ahead.

Maybe that's why I rely on the ERE forums so much-there's always somebody somewhere that always knows a lot more than I do about everything....

ffj
Posts: 2046
Joined: Thu Aug 26, 2010 3:16 am

Re: "Why I Make Terrible Decisions,or,poverty thoughts"

Post by ffj »

@GandK
Hadn't thought of that and is possibly true. Someone with that affliction can still determine right from wrong though, correct?

@DA
To me it reinforces that there are more kind-hearted people than not. People want to do good, and when a story is carefully crafted to serve people's altruistic inclinations, there you go. Here's an example of random people just wanting to help some guy caught in a larger story:

http://abcnews.go.com/US/donations-pour ... d=26424839

@1task

Yeah, her story was riddled with excuses to the point of ridiculousness. Poor people don't have the ability or special know-how to properly cook broccoli? Please. Are powerless to prevent pregnancies? Can't afford a 33 cent toothbrush and a tube of toothpaste for a dollar? Floss for another dollar?

The larger issue is why do we allow a drastically lower standard for other people, which is reinforced with donations, when those same excuses would be absolutely ridiculous and inexcusable in our own lives?

jacob
Site Admin
Posts: 11768
Joined: Fri Jun 28, 2013 8:38 pm
Location: USA, Zone 5b, Koppen Dfa, Elev. 620ft, Walkscore 73
Contact:

Re: "Why I Make Terrible Decisions,or,poverty thoughts"

Post by jacob »

@ffj - The problem as I've come to see it is a case of Liebig's law of the minimum and wrong projections.

Assumptions:
1) All humans need to know how to floss, cook broccoli, ... make money to spend on stuff IN ORDER to live good lives.
2) For the middle class, money to spend is the limiting factor. (This is why the middle class "struggles" whenever they paycheck is reduced.)
3) For the poverty class, having the mental energy to plan and execute, etc. whatever is the limiting factor.

In helping the poverty class, the middle class mistakenly believes that's what's holding the poverty class back is the same as what's holding the middle class back, namely lack of money. Hence donations. However, this is not the case. This is also why more money won't help anyone but those bordering on middle class already.

PS: From an ERE perspective, what's holding the middle class back is a lack of alternative capital like knowledge and ability [to do more than one's specialization]. Removing those limitations is what allows ERE to spend less. People with more limitations on their capabilities need to spend more because they're compensating with services from the economy instead of from their own "capital".

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liebig%27s ... he_minimum

7Wannabe5
Posts: 5538
Joined: Fri Oct 18, 2013 9:03 am

Re: "Why I Make Terrible Decisions,or,poverty thoughts"

Post by 7Wannabe5 »

Jacob said: a lack of alternative capital like knowledge and ability
I suppose when you are talking about adults this might apply only to the middle class but when you are talking about children it applies to everyone. I challenge anybody who doesn't think they can be part of the solution to spend one day tutoring children in a poverty zone. Donate 20 minutes of your time and you can be the one who teaches a child how to perform subtraction on numbers with more than one digit and then she will have that skill for the rest of her life. The limiting factor in skill acquisition in the poverty zone where I am currently teaching is definitely number of adult instructors rather than learning ability of the children.

jacob
Site Admin
Posts: 11768
Joined: Fri Jun 28, 2013 8:38 pm
Location: USA, Zone 5b, Koppen Dfa, Elev. 620ft, Walkscore 73
Contact:

Re: "Why I Make Terrible Decisions,or,poverty thoughts"

Post by jacob »

@7w5 - I was talking about adults only. What you're saying about children is also why the countries that make "everything equal" for the children as young as possible tend to have the highest rates of social mobility.

7Wannabe5
Posts: 5538
Joined: Fri Oct 18, 2013 9:03 am

Re: "Why I Make Terrible Decisions,or,poverty thoughts"

Post by 7Wannabe5 »

Jacob said: What you're saying about children is also why the countries that make "everything equal" for the children as young as possible tend to have the highest rates of social mobility.
Right. The problem in my neighborhood is that the vast majority of the children have functionally illiterate or non-English-speaking parents. So, there is no opportunity for instruction or review outside of the classroom. This even applies to subjects such as mathematics because the modern method of teaching and standard of skill-acquisition requires the child to write a verbal response to a question such as "What strategy did you use to solve this problem?" after doing a set of calculations. Therefore, the only way these kids are going to have a fair chance to catch up with their peers is if they have significant one-on-one time with adults other than their parents. Every classroom I have been in has had several children with no English whatsoever and several children with severe behavioral problems. I think the school district is really doing a heroic job in attempting to educate under these circumstances and all the children do at least receive free breakfasts and lunches and there are adequate instructional materials.

Post Reply