Good post Sky. Arthur Schopenhauer +1 for financial independence and recognizing hedonic treadmill.
Here is the chapter where that aphorism (relating to relative wealth) comes from:
https://monadnock.net/schopenhauer/wisdom-3.html
Good post Sky. Arthur Schopenhauer +1 for financial independence and recognizing hedonic treadmill.
I'm just an anectdote, but I have gained plenty of muscle mass from a lower protein diet (don't track it all the time but I would guess about 60-80 grams / day at 200ish lbs) all from plants. Strength gains are fairly slow, but gains are always slow when you aren't new to resistance training anymore. As to the post exercise protein, definitely you want protein after training, but newer studies (https://www.jospt.org/doi/full/10.2519/jospt.2018.0615) highlight criticisms of the anabolic window studies, as they had < 20 participants and fairly sketchy results. Conclusion below.Lemur wrote: ↑Tue Jul 19, 2022 3:00 pmThe low protein requirements in the past have made me hesitant, but I'm starting to gather some data on that which is easing my concerns. The evidence around decreases in most metabolic diseases and cancers is pretty robust (ex. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24606898/) but most of my concerns are with losing lean body mass. The evidence gets shakier there I think but I'm looking. I'm experimenting with this again, and I'm not seeing real life loss in strength yet so...will proceed forward and monitor.
For context, Longo's protein recommendation is no more than 0.31 to 0.36 grams per pound of body weight. So a 150 pound male would eat between 46.5 grams and 54.0 grams of protein; most of which will be from plant-based sources such as beans/legumes (and Longo is supportive of fish 2-3x a week). My concern is that this recommendation (the top range is simply the RDA) is too low for maintaining muscle mass especially in a caloric deficit. He does state to justify an increase of 25-30 grams post exercise for those engaged in those activities (and that evidence is also supported by the need for protein synthesis).
If I can't find a study...my idea was to just follow along with the guidelines and just track real world changes. It will be evident if say I can't do as many pushups or pullups and I start to see performance loss.
I think they agree with Longo above there, 25-30g protein somewhat near to training. Adding carbs to that didn't matter at all .Based on current evidence, it appears clear that any effect of protein timing on muscle hypertrophy, if in fact there is one, is relatively small. Total daily protein intake is by far the most important factor in promoting exercise-induced muscle development. Research indicates that consumption of 1.6 to 2.2 g/kg per day is needed to optimize results.16 While nutrient timing potentially can be a beneficial strategy for enhancing muscular gains, the “window of opportunity” is not as narrow as often purported. Rather, the window exists on a fairly wide continuum, and its effects on muscle growth ultimately depend on when nutrients were consumed prior to the training bout. Research shows that the anabolic effects of an individual mixed meal last up to 6 hours.12 Thus, provided that such a meal is consumed within about 3 to 4 hours prior to a workout (or possibly even longer, depending on the size of the meal), the need for immediate postexercise nutrient consumption is abated. For those who train partially or fully fasted, on the other hand, consuming protein immediately postworkout becomes increasingly more important to elicit anabolism. If one's primary training goal is to maximize muscle growth, it seems prudent to consume high-quality protein (at a dose of approximately 0.4–0.5 g/kg of lean body mass) both pre-exercise and postexercise within about 4 to 6 hours of each other, depending on meal size.
Reputable enough I'll take it for now as I think at this point I may just be looking for bias confirmation...To increase muscle mass in combination with physical activity, it is recommended that a person that lifts weights regularly or is training for a running or cycling event eat a range of 1.2-1.7 grams of protein per kilogram of body weight per day, or 0.5 to 0.8 grams per pound of body weight. Consequently, the same 75 kilogram individual should increase their protein intake to 75 grams (300 calories) to 128 grams (512 calories) in order to gain muscle mass. This level of intake can generally be met through diet alone and without additional protein and amino acid supplementation.
Funny, the author of a story last week in Vanity Fair about the demographic issues surrounding The Villages and the Boomers in general said the exact same thing.
His book came out last week as well:There’s an insistence to that community; the Villages cannot be an easy place for an introvert. The ubiquitous golf carts often have the names of the passengers emblazoned in script on their hoods, man in the driver’s seat, woman on the passenger side: Dennis and Sally; John and Beth. Signs outside of houses often offer the same information. There’s no excuse for not knowing your neighbor in the Villages.